*
Search
Cedar-clad single-story home with a glazed entrance, gray flagstone approach, autumn maple foliage, and a deep front lawn.

Broomall's Square Pizza Changed Hands This Year, From the Banquet Hall to the Takeout Counter

October 15, 2026

"The sauce's still on top. The pizza's still square." That is how Delco Today opened its July report on the arrival of Pica's Italian Market in Broomall. Then it named what had changed: "after months of goodbyes, construction, and a stubborn gas line, Pica's is officially back in Delaware County."

About 0.9 miles away by car, Rize Pizza spent the same summer behind construction paper at Lawrence Park Shopping Center. Put the two stories together and you get a 2026 role swap for Broomall's square pies. The family that spent decades hosting wedding receptions in its dining rooms now runs a leaner market built for takeout. The shop that made its name on takeout is building its first full-service dining room.

Pica's Came to Sussex Boulevard Smaller on Purpose

The Pica story starts in 1941. That year Frank Pica Sr. opened a brick-oven pizzeria at 62nd and Race streets in West Philadelphia, with a few tables and a takeout counter. In 1956 he and his son, Frank Pica Jr., moved the business to 7803 West Chester Pike in Upper Darby. There it grew into a full-service restaurant with dining rooms and banquet halls. Delaware County families booked those rooms for wedding receptions, showers, birthdays, graduations, reunions and funeral luncheons. In 2017, Philadelphia Magazine named Pica's "Best Red Gravy Italian" in its Best of Philly awards.

The Upper Darby location closed in May 2026 after 70 years on West Chester Pike. On July 16, Pica's Italian Market Broomall soft-opened at 1101 Sussex Boulevard, Suite 10. The third generation runs it now: Angela Pica Oandasan and Frank Pica.

The move was not a straight relocation. Delco Today reported that the banquet halls and sprawling floor plan are gone. The family replaced them with an Italian market "built for grab-and-go dinners, stocked freezers, and catering orders, not long Sunday sit-downs." Besides the signature rectangular pie, the case and menu carry mozzarella sticks, cheesesteaks, chicken Parmesan sandwiches, hoagies, salads, antipasto and desserts. On its own website, Pica's advertises ToGO catering with platters and family-style options. That service picks up a small piece of the party business the banquet halls used to handle.

The opening came with a limited menu because of the gas-connection issue. The family said more items would come once new staff were trained. As of this week, the Pica's menu page shows both a "Menu" and a "SOFT OPEN MENU," covering salads, sandwiches, entrées, pizza and desserts. The page still carries a note that the menu will grow as staff are trained. We could not find a grand-opening announcement or confirmation that the full menu is now standard. Calling ahead before a larger order is the practical move.

Rize Built the Dining Room Pica's Left Behind

Rize Pizza sits at 1991 Sproul Road in Lawrence Park Shopping Center. It closed in April for a renovation that turned out bigger than a refresh. The pizzeria took over the neighboring storefront to create a full-service dining area. Delco Today called that a first for a pizzeria that built its reputation on takeout. In June, Patch quoted the plan Rize posted on Facebook:

"We will have full service dining on the left and our current space on the right will be freshly remodeled for the takeout you already know and love!"

The job ran longer than expected. According to Delco Today's September update, work picked up over the summer once McGonigle & Company Builders took over as contractor. Takeout came back on September 2, along with patio dining. In that same mid-September update, crews were still finishing the sit-down room and no official opening date had been set for it. We have not found anything newer confirming that the dining room has opened. For now, the safe assumption is takeout and the patio.

Owner Julia Angelos took inspiration from her grandparents, who ran their own restaurant decades ago. Delco Today credits her creative menu, customer input and community-minded approach with making Rize a local destination. Pica's started in 1941 with a few tables and a counter and grew into banquet halls. Rize is now making its own first move from counter to tables. Both kitchens have a family restaurant somewhere in the story, and in 2026 they moved in opposite directions.

Two Square Pies, Built Differently

Both shops serve a square pie, and the two are built differently.

  • Pica's rectangular pie: Cheese goes on the bottom and sauce on top. Delco Today calls it the pie that made the family famous, and it survived the move unchanged.
  • Rize's square "Rize Crust": Sesame seeds go on the bottom of the crust. Rize also makes traditional round pies and a gluten-free cauliflower crust.
  • Rize's specialty lineup: Upside Down, Angry Bird, Southern Belle, Green Dream, Venus and Rib Eye Cheesesteak.
  • Beyond pizza: Rize's September 2026 menu adds salads, wraps, starters and desserts. Pica's leans on Italian-American sandwiches, antipasto and catering trays.

One is a recipe carried over from a West Philadelphia counter in the 1940s. The other is an artisan-style crust built around new combinations. Both now sit inside the same short drive.

Lawrence Park's Fall Shuffle Ends at the Same Address

Rize is not the only Lawrence Park storefront to reopen this fall. At the end of September, The Delco Store came back to the center at 1991 Sproul Road, next to Five Guys. That is the same street address Delco Today gives for Rize.

The shop is also known as Delco Original Trading Company, and it has moved around before. Founders Erik Schmidt and Lara Lewis started it as a seasonal pop-up at Springfield Mall during the 2020 holiday season. It later found a home at Lawrence Park. While its new Lawrence Park space was being built, it moved temporarily to the former Party City in Springfield. Patch also covered the return at the end of September. The mix inside is the same as before: Delco shirts, county-branded gifts, hats and accessories, plus gear for the Eagles, Flyers, Phillies, 76ers and other Philadelphia teams.

Federal Realty, the center's owner, lists Lawrence Park among its Philadelphia-region properties and describes a multi-million-dollar renovation there. Rize's takeout counter came back on September 2 and The Delco Store reopened at the end of the month, so a pizza run and a stop for team gear can now share one parking lot.

Before You Go

Hours have shifted since the summer, and our sources don't all agree:

  • Pica's Italian Market, 1101 Sussex Boulevard, Suite 10: The July report listed Tuesday through Saturday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sunday 11 a.m. to 7 p.m., and said hours might change. The current Google Maps listing shows Tuesday through Sunday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., closed Mondays. The shop's phone number is 610-789-7770.
  • Rize Pizza, 1991 Sproul Road: The September 2026 menu lists Monday through Saturday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sunday noon to 8 p.m.
  • Getting between them: Google Maps routes the 0.9-mile drive from Pica's to Lawrence Park via Parkway Drive and Reed Road, about three minutes.

Two Marple events this month pair well with either stop. On Saturday, October 17, from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m., the Marple Historical Society holds Colonial Harvest Day at the Thomas Massey House, 469 Lawrence Road. The day includes house tours, blacksmithing, hearth cooking, children's activities and music from the Marple Community Band, and admission is free. On Saturday, October 24, Marple Township holds its Trunk or Treat from 6:30 to 8:30 p.m. at the Township Building, 227 S. Sproul Road, according to the Marple Mag events calendar. It's free, and anyone bringing a decorated car has to register.

A sauce-on-top tray from Sussex Boulevard on the way home from the Massey House is one easy pairing. A Rize Crust pie eaten on the patio before the trunks open on Sproul Road is another.

The Pica family's move from banquet halls to a market counter is a reminder that a long-held place sometimes works best in a new shape. Many of the Broomall homeowners we work with face a similar question when a house that once fit a big family no longer fits their life. If you're weighing what your Marple Township home could become for its next owner, Fizzano Family of Associates will walk you through it as a family business, with a free consultation and home valuation and the same steady communication from first conversation to closing.

Work With Us

We all know that the world has changed and Real Estate has as well. If you are contemplating selling or buying, please allow me the opportunity to talk with you about my “Win/Win” Real Estate solution!